Four Lessons in Columbia Democracy: Don't Elect Trustees, Just Leave
The Specter Board of Trustees
Following their earlier exchange in the Columbia Spectator, two Columbia law professors faced off at an AAUP-sponsored debate over whether faculty, students, and staff should elect representatives to the Board of Trustees. David Pozen made a compelling case for democratizing Columbia's governance, while Joshua Mitts offered a spirited defense of the status quo.
For those of us wondering who actually runs Columbia, who holds its leadership accountable, and why the university community has so little say in consequential decisions, Mitts helpfully offered four lessons.
The Specter wishes to clarify that, while this is a satirical account, the arguments themselves required remarkably little embellishment.
Lesson 1: We already have enough democracy.
Faculty committees deliberate, administrators consult, presidents decide, and trustees oversee.
This was reassuring news to those of us who somehow missed being consulted about Columbia's negotiations with the Trump administration and the resulting changes to university governance.
Lesson 2: If we elect trustees, they might represent the people who elected them.
Mitts worried that elected trustees would arrive with electoral mandates and feel obliged to represent their constituencies.
Imagine the danger.
Fortunately, our current trustees are spared the burden of answering to anyone affected by their decisions.
Lesson 3: We should all want a weak board.
Mitts argued that the president makes the decisions, not the trustees.
This will come as news to Claire Shipman, who went directly from co-chair of the Board of Trustees to acting president in the middle of negotiations with the Trump administration. The board is weak, it seems, right up until it needs a president. Then it is the president.
Lesson 4: If you don't like it, you can leave.
Mitts invoked Albert Hirschman’s exit versus voice, arguing that the threat of dissatisfied faculty leaving is a powerful check on leadership.
Hirschman’s book was called Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Columbia’s edition keeps the exit, expects the loyalty, and leaves out the voice.
Faculty who have spent decades building research programs, mentoring students, and bringing in grants may exercise their democratic influence by updating their CVs and applying elsewhere.
The system works. Just don't ask who it works for.